Reading vs doing tai chi
I read books to understand tai ji. I read books to find answers to why this move must be like this and why the hand must be there. I read to know more, to understand more. My conversation with my teacher told me something entirely different.
He reads to confirm his understanding. He buys lots of books when the books are on the shelves. But he just puts it aside, until he’s ready to read them. That’s when he’s learnt enough about a certain form and feel confident of his experience. Then only he consults the books.
I guess unconsciously, I am aware of my “lack of experience” part of my training. That’s why i’m in a push hand class to test out the theories, and hopefully gain a better understanding of the theories. Never have I thought I should leave the books aside first and try to “feel” it.
Incidentally, I have left the books behind nowadays – which in retrospect, is probably a good thing! 
If you like what you read, you can follow me on RSS, by email, on Twitter, or on Facebook.
Related posts:
Category: Life in Motion | Tags: books, push hands, Tai Chi 2 comments »
September 4th, 2006 at 6:08 pm
that’s unusual….normally one should confirm understanding with teacher rather than book unless of course the teacher has passed on. even then when words confirm one’s understanding or not depends on one’s interpretation. a matter of chicken or egg first….:-)
September 5th, 2006 at 8:32 pm
Reminds me of a quote by TT Liang:
“If I believe entirely in books, better not read books; if I rely entirely on teachers, better not have teachers.”