Techniques vs skill
I’m not sure if this is a common misunderstanding, but I thought I bring it up anyway to find out more from the community.
I have come to realize that some people try to learn techiques rather than try to learn the skill. They relish in the satisfaction of knowing more and more techniques, without actually learning the skill.
Is that possible? Isn’t knowing more techniques a sign of increasing your skill?
I suppose certain techniques require a different level of skill set to perform. But that’s not the point, and should not be used as the reason to perfect the technique. We should instead focus on perfecting the skill rather than the technique.
Take push hands for example. There are many ways to counter attack a person. Most ways I’ve seen are not truly using the softness of Tai Chi. Most people rely on knowing a certain way to move their hands or a certain way to turn their body and when this is perfected, they are able to wait and anticipate when to execute this technique. After this one technique, they start to accumulate other techniques and will eventually pass off this collection of techniques as skill.
While this is useful and may seem to work on the outside, it misses the whole point of learning Tai Chi.
We’ve heard of formlessness, i.e. using non-specific moves. This is when you’ve perfected an art and do not need to actually use any partiular form of that art to show that you truly understand the art. With such good understanding, you are then able to apply the art in more ways than one.
But formlessness do start with the existence of “form” to realize the power of “no form”. This is why we learn Tai Chi form first before learning the art. This is why we learn the notes of music before expressing music. This is why I learn the alphabets and some words first before writing a post like this. I don’t need a large vocabulary to write what I write. I just need to understand the words and then string them together to tell you this story.
I believe this is true for any art, and should form the reason for learning the art. So don’t just be a collector of techniques. Learn the true art.
If you like what you read, you can follow me on RSS, by email, on Twitter, or on Facebook.
Related posts:
Category: Life in Motion | Tags: push hands, Tai Chi, writing 2 comments »
November 29th, 2008 at 10:26 am
From my point of view, this might be one of the main distinctions between external and internal martial arts.
February 6th, 2009 at 9:22 am
[...] to highlight a point in my previous post about how little words we use, I’ve analysed that same post and according to [...]